A crypto exchange service can operate without a registered legal entity, but this does not exempt its owner from liability for compliance with applicable laws. This is particularly important when its activities involve international transactions, servicing clients from the EU, and transactions involving cryptocurrency wallets that are independently controlled by users.
Earlier this year, the owner of such a service approached AA Lawrange. The business was already operating but had neither a license nor a formalized corporate structure. The client wanted to assess the legal implications of its current operations and determine how to organize its future activities in compliance with regulatory requirements.
Interested in the basis of the comprehensive legal audit we conducted? We are ready to share the details.
What Issues Did Our Lawyers Need to Address First?
Unlike projects that are only preparing to launch, this crypto exchange service was already conducting transactions. Therefore, the legal assessment had to cover both the future business model and the possible consequences of its previous activities. With this in mind, the owner was interested in several areas, which subsequently became the basis of our work:
- Identifying regulatory and criminal law risks associated with providing crypto exchange services without a license or legal entity.
- Assessing the applicability of the European MiCA regulation, Travel Rule requirements, and sanctions restrictions.
- Analyzing operations involving self-hosted wallets and existing anti-money laundering and customer verification (AML/KYC) procedures.
- Determining the possible legal consequences if law enforcement authorities make inquiries regarding previously conducted transactions.
- Considering options for changing the corporate and operational structure of the business, including through the involvement of an international company.
The client needed more than a separate consultation on obtaining a license. They needed an assessment of the legal position of the entire project. This assessment was intended to help determine which aspects of the business required changes and which solutions should be considered before continuing operations.
Can Registering a Company Abroad Solve the Licensing Issue?
Registering a crypto exchange service in another country does not automatically grant it the right to operate in the international market. A company may be registered in one jurisdiction while providing services to clients in other countries, where separate requirements apply to cryptocurrency businesses.
- In particular, establishing a corporate structure outside the EU does not, in itself, exempt a business from complying with European regulatory requirements if the service’s activities fall within their scope. What matters is not only the company’s place of registration but also the nature of its services, target markets, and methods of interaction with clients.
Therefore, when considering international restructuring, it is necessary to assess not only the conditions for registering a legal entity but also the possibility of lawfully providing services in the countries where the crypto exchange service will operate.
From Risk Analysis to Restructuring Options: What Did the Legal Audit of the Client’s Crypto Exchange Cover?
Lawrange lawyers examined the regulatory, criminal law, and operational risks associated with the existing business model. The work covered several areas:
- Determining the legal status of the crypto exchange service. We examined how its activities could be classified within the EU, taking into account the absence of a license and proper formalization of the business’s corporate structure.
- Analyzing the applicability of the MiCA Regulation. We determined which provisions of the European crypto-asset regulatory framework could apply to the client’s business model and what risks could arise from non-compliance, particularly regarding the authorization requirements for crypto-asset service providers.
- Reviewing Travel Rule requirements and sanctions restrictions. We examined the rules governing the transfer of information about the senders and recipients of crypto-assets, as well as the sanctions-related aspects of the service’s operations.
- Assessing criminal law risks. We investigated potential grounds for liability associated with operating a crypto exchange service without a license or legal entity.
- Analyzing AML/KYC procedures and cryptocurrency wallet transactions. We reviewed the existing financial monitoring and customer verification model, as well as the risks associated with using self-hosted wallets, the private keys to which are controlled by the users themselves.
- Assessing the risks associated with previous transactions. We determined the possible legal consequences of inquiries from law enforcement authorities regarding transactions conducted before the legal audit began. A change in the corporate structure does not automatically eliminate liability for past activities.
- Developing business restructuring options. We proposed models for transferring business operations to an international structure in Panama and using a nominee service.
- Preparing recommendations for the client. We developed proposals for reducing legal and operational risks, along with a sequence of further steps for the project’s operations.
In this case, we did not limit ourselves to finding an individual solution to the licensing issue. We needed to consider how changing the operating model would affect the legal position of the service and its owner. That is why the proposed options for future operations were not considered in isolation but in the context of all the risks analyzed.
Result: Comprehensive Legal Assessment and an Action Plan for Future Operations
Following the comprehensive legal audit, our lawyers provided the owner of the crypto exchange service with a detailed consultation addressing all the issues raised. The client received an assessment of regulatory, criminal law, and operational risks, as well as business restructuring options, including the involvement of an international structure in Panama.
The main outcome was a practical roadmap for the project’s future operations. It included recommendations for reducing legal and operational risks, taking into account the existing business model and the possible consequences of previously conducted transactions.
Planning to restructure your cryptocurrency business or assess the risks of your current operations? Contact Lawrange lawyers to conduct a legal audit, analyze regulatory requirements, and prepare recommendations for the future operations of your project.